very different voice great def someone to watch for

she is so cool. ^___^ and i love her hair/earrings.
i like her theme of changing the top 40. top 40 songs are usually boring generic pop, ugh.

so cool and unique! love her :D!

I really like your unique voice that fills me with awe and leaves me wanting more. Congrats to the top 24!

Really refreshing! Go girl!

Really refreshing! Go girl!

Want to hear Lily sing more. Love to see her perform

Lilly, that voice... love it! I know that you give it your all and you'll do well. Best of luck!

AWESOME! I love Lilly! This chick can sing and has the most memorable and interesting voice and style they've ever had on AI. She's going to be a huge star and I will be buying anything she puts out there. LOVE HER!

LILLY AND CRYSTAL ARE ALREADY STARS!!!!!!!!
YOU GUYS SHOULD BE BEST FRIENDS!!

I knew Lilly would make it through. She will be in the top three contestents

lilly is by far my favorite. i know she will conitue to capture america will her uniqueness.

lily is my fav for season 9!

love lilly -- she should check out the australian artist Sia Furler -- she could do some amazing covers of Sia

Lily, i love your sound but girl, you need to change the colour of your hair. It looks grey on the t.v and it is not flattering. Just trying to help. If it's supposed to be blonde, you need to change the tone. If it's supposed to be grey, then I'm backing off.

Lily - That is not true. Your hair does not look gray on television. Miss vivaciousv needs to change the color on her television. Your hair is soooo cool and is very you. Do not listen to that negative comment. I don't think you will. I love your looks and your style. You are adorable. You and DiDi are my favorites. Crystal is really talented but I think she should have been a star a long time ago. I wish there could be more than one winner but for me it's between 2. You and DiDi. How about a great Michael Jackson song. He had so many. He sang this but I think it was a Supremes song. "Love is Here" You know "love is here and oh my darling now your gone". Great song. I would love to hear you sing it.

All I have to say is the judges did not give you enough praise. I loved you. I am a big fan of Patsy Cline. She had one of the most incredible voices of all time. You did that song justice. I am telling you, YOU were WONDERFUL! I was so afraid when they announced the song. I just knew you would change it up and make it rock. I was worried you were going to change it too much but you didn't. You changed it in the perfect places. I love you and I'm pulling for you.

I like Patsy Cline, but it was not good for you. Do some Flyleaf, it fits your style better. You have a good voice.

I was taken aback when they announced your name Lily. I just couldn't believe it was you that had to leave. You have been cheated and we have been cheated. You are just wonderful Lily and you will make it without American Idol. Someone will want to write songs for you and give you a recording contract. Have you written any songs? I'm sure you have. I hate to see you go. I thought you had a real good chance of winning It is really a crying shame.

YOU GOT ROBBED !!!!!!!!!!!!!111

Lily I am a huge fan of yours!!!, don't give up!! you have it going on girlie!!! I heard you and I am all about your vocals!! what you did with Patsy Clines song was amazing!! I cannot believe you got voted off you were far better than some of the other talent that made it through!! I hope you get a recording contract so I can be purchasing your music in the future!! so sorry I think you got robbed you deserve to be in the top twelve!!!!!

Lily, not to worry, I have been in the music biz with the greats...you have a unique look and platform. Not to worry...you will get picked up. You were one of my favorites!

What is up with America!! Katie should have went home, she can't even sing!! Lily should have remained, she is the talent and very confident. Go home Katie little girl!! stupid voters!!!!!!!!!!

I wish someone will discover Lily and take her under their wing, she is really one of the best next to Crystal and Didi. I thought she'd be in top 2 or 3. Katie and the red head girl got nothing on Lily, stupid voters man!!!!!!!!!

lilly rocks my socks off! I loved her uniqueness and I was EXTREMELY EXTREMELY EXTREMELLLLYYYYYY SHOCKED wow i absolutely couldn't believe it :o

My husband & I are totally frustrated and sad! We think there should be a recount because somebody messed up. No way should Lilly be going home. If the judges can right this wrong I hope they have the courage & not just sit on their hands & let this BIG mistake go by & bring Lilly back! We have never voted before but this year we did for Lilly on ever preformance she did. This is for you Lilly: You are a very rare true talent & we will be watching for anything that you do in the future and we are truly sorry & wish you the best!

Lilly, I am a 53 yr old woman, who has been watching and voting for years. I really dont know how it happened that you did not make the final 12. They need to count again. You got rooked. I am so very sorry, thought you were going all the way. Voted for you and only you alot. Keep things going, and I will buy your CD anytime.

Lilly i miss u on the showwwww!
PLEASE make lots of music i love ur voice soo much

Uve been my fav since i saw ur audition and i teared up when u left.. (no joke lol)
and if u really really wanna be totally awesome, u could make a ****.. cus i could listen to u sing alll day. Keep going!! PLEASE!

Ur bigggggest fan, Kara :)

Lilly , My girlfriend an I REALLY like you and your unique style. We are praying for you to suceed and want to see more performances and songs! We would love to hear from you as well! She is a musician and I just love music and we both felt you were #1 and should have been in the top 3 for sure! You even did Ella's song better than Ella! Tom(the Amazing) and Karen!