Lilly Scott has the most incredible voice! Reminds me of Norah Jones!

Lilly is so far, my favorite girl this season. I love her voice, and "indie" is my favorite genre. Also, she can rock the platinum blonde! love it!

Yes Lilly you do have an awesome personality. You were born for this opportunity. Go Lilly!!!! All the way.

i love her!

she winnnnnnsss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You make me wish I owned a major record label. I'd sign you in a heartbeat, and just let you do what you wanted to do. I hope you get the right songs to choose from. I have a bad vibe about the whole theme theme. If you get the right songs to choose from you'll be untouchable, and that's what I'm hoping for. Bring the ear candy, my itunes is ready to go.

Lilly I think you quite possible are meant to sing "Scar" By Missy Higgins.

This is cool.

Lilly,
You should sing To Sir With Love, by Lulu!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lilly - you so did not deserve to be voted off tonight but your star is so much brighter than the likes of any Idol.

You said that you, "don't know what America wants", but I say, don't worry about America! There are lots of other people around the world who are going to want your music, so stay true to yourself and give those of us who DO want to hear more of you what YOU want to us to hear!

You're a breath of fresh air and I can't wait to breathe in more of you.

LIlli you are awesome. I can't believe you didn't make it. America does not understand your style. You have the most original voice of the group.

My husband & I are totally frustrated and sad! We think there should be a recount because somebody messed up. No way should Lilly be going home. If the judges can right this wrong I hope they have the courage & not just sit on their hands & let this BIG mistake go by & bring Lilly back! We have never voted before but this year we did for Lilly on ever preformance she did. This is for you Lilly: You are a very rare true talent & we will be watching for anything that you do in the future and we are truly sorry & wish you the best!

Lilly, you got robbed, I hope your singing career takes off. I look forward to your first CD. You should be in the top 12. We will miss you.

I am sorry you didn't make it to the top twelve. You should have. I was so shocked, in fact, me, my husband and daughter were really in shock. Good luck to you as you make your first CD. We'll buy it!!! Love you voice.

Bring Lilly Back.Period.Bring her back.