I still can't figure out why they sent him home. After hearing Johnny sing this song. Joshua sounded dull last night.

I still can not figure this out. WHY isn't JK on the show!? Something must have happened that we didn't see. He just posted a video on twitter from youtube (a new one) that is just sick-ridiculous talent there. I am so, so disappointed that he isn't on the show anymore. He was definitely a front-runner. I wish someone would explain.

My guess:  If Johnny made Top 24, he would not be eligible to participate in future seasons of Idol.  Phillip is running away with this season.  Johnny could have backed out and is planning on coming back next year to take the #1 spot.  Then again, he could've just really ticked off the producers who gave him the boot.  You never know.

RIDICULOUS that they got rid of him, he could/should have won!

Can someone please tell me what the conspiracy is regarding Johnny Keyser?? I thought for sure they would bring him back last night. By far one of the best, most soulful, "whole package" contestants EVER!! Almost makes me want to skip the whole season. Really, what is up?? Super bummed and confused. Hope some record producer has the good sense to snatch him up or he comes back next year and the judges aren't on drugs then!! Geeeeezzzzz!!!!

I looked back at all of the 4 guys and Johnny is THE ONE!  Bring him back PLEASE!

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE bring Johnny back!! He is brilliant, so talented, he has got it all. Talent, looks, personality...he is destined to be the winner. I said it the when he auditioned and I've not changed my mind!! So you gotta bring him back, PLEASE.

Johnny Keyser = awesome

Please bring "The Tudors " guy Johnny Keyser back! I can't believe you let him go! His voice, style and personality are amazing!!! Please, please bring him back!!!

Seriously I can't understand how this kid got cut.  He has it all, he can sing he has looks and he seems like a nice person.  I hope he is the Wild Card otherwise there will be no eye candy for us ladies to drool over.

I am SO disappointed Johnny Keyser did not make the Vegas cut!!!! He was so memorable and has an incredible voice. Don't know if I will watch the show. Not interested anymore.

Why, why, why was he cut? He's much more interesting than many of those who survived the Vegas round. This reminds me of Colton Dixon getting cut last year before the public voting. An outrage!

Right, Idol did not even show Keyser's group in Vegas. LIsten, Idol is a very, very, very scripted show. Who knew?!?! A tv show that is fiction but pretends to be real ;o) The tragic part is that instead of just fooling the viewers, this show fools young people who just found out how unfair and senseless this society can be. Enjoy the show as long as you can remember it's not real, and your vote doesn't count....OH! Maybe it is real...

no , u didn't miss anything. they didn't show his group. and now his vegas audition of wake up little susie is not playable. it is the only one that has an error message. hmm.

Did I miss something when he played in Vegas, but I did not see him sing ?? Did they have video of him playing and singing (in his group) in Vegas on the eposide ? All I saw was he and his group in the pool in Vegas, but they didnt show him singing ? Am I wrong with this ??

I am ABSOLUTELY BAFFLED that Johnny did not make it through tonight. I had him making it to the top 5. There is a lot of talent, but there is not doubt they made a huge mistake not passing him through. HORRIBLE decision.

This boy will definately be the "eye" candy this year - and he has a great voice to go with it!

He's so my favorite!! I love this guy!! I'm voting for him!

I love him!!

Johnny K's singing is outta this world-gave me goosebumps...sounded like he was channeling Sam Cooke!!

@

Johnny is WOW!

Who else is voting for him? <3

you can sing boy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@

loveee this guy!!!!

This boy is crazy. Jennifer can't take it?? I can't even take it. LOVE IT! "Just like th river I've been running..." #STILL SEXY...