Johnny Keyser was the winner, I hope they bring him back.

very disappointed in the judging. They certainly like all the screamers.

i cant believe they still have the cowboy!!! they let a few good ones go and kept him-- his days are numbered!!

To Patricia Kemp ....im thinkin theyre probably thinkin if uve really got what it takes and have awesome talent u should b able to perform in any situation....solo...groups...diff music style...etc...american idol has to PERFECT lol from what im seein. After the last episode when cowboy got thru but Johnny didnt...i about died..makes me wonder...wtf are they thinking????

I like cowboy boy..he's cute..a little overbearing but cute..I think he has potential

I cant believe that Johnnys been eliminated but country nerd has made it thru...no way hes better . . Johnnys a natural u can tell...n has the looks...all of it...theres more i dont agree with but that was my big number 1 complaint lol..=)

If you really want to see some good singers, tune in to THE VOICE on Mondays at 7pm on NBC network.

a guy is gonna win again this year...*YAWN

And also you make them stay up all night ONE night - -when in the industry you can take more than ONE night to get ready to perform. Not even close and I am losing interest. I love Jennifer, Steve and Randy but the executive producers are going to see that this preliminary stuff could be shortened...

I am very disappointed in the IDOL this year of the sensationalism of the pressure you are placing on these young people. You say " you are going to have this type of stress in the industry" but you are wrong. They will at least be in their element not singing with four other people. How is this really a way to judge the AI. Give me THE VOICE any day in how you have done it this year. Getting tired of the build up to it and too many passing out, etc.

Glad we got to hear some talent and not so much nonsense.

Glad we got to hear some talent and not so much nonsense.

This is what I wanted to watch American idol for....these Vegas performances were soooo much fun to watch...this is where it's at for us viewers!!!!!!..now you've got it!...better than any other singing show on t.v. w/ those Vegas performances!!!

Also I am 51 yrs old so I could care less about looks and can listen to the voices without being distracted! Facebook me AI...

I think they need to let me vote with them! I can hear pretty good!

Why is the top contestants leaked? Especially when they are told they better Not say anything! This list better not be right. I am getting tired of watching since I know who goes through.

go colton dixon :)

I'm not watching another show since they let Johnny Keyser go... He had the voice and the look.

@Sai : That was Joshua Ledet singing "Jar of Hearts"

So bummed Johnnys out! :-{

Hmmm, was anyone else offended by the ridilian comment by the voice coach? As a mom of a child with adhd, it wasn't cool!!!!!

Not Crazy about the Genre, Sorry....But some talent!!

I trust the judges to put the best 24 contestants together and that's what they're doing right now. They did a fantastic job last year with putting together the most talented and diverse group in the show's history. They know what they're doing and in the end we will have the cream of the crop going through to the live shows. People just have to have a little patience with them.

is this live cause i would love to run into some of you guys

ya right! fox having broadcast issues, so my cable company didn't air it! I recorded 2 hours of a frozen screen and didn't even know it! I missed the show!

I don't know what they're looking for. They are sending home a ton of talented ones and keeping randoms. I was looking for Johnny tonight next thing I knew he was cut? I just hope it doesn't end up like last season.

Lauren will win! She is the dark horse....watch her.

The group performances are the biggest screw job to contestants and makes the judges look like jackasses. It needs a restructering.

THE JUDGES GOT IT SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WRONG WHEN YOU VOTED OFF JOHNNY KEYSER!!!!!!!!! HE WOULD OF WON!! So sad... don't know if I am interested in watching now! That blow was way beyond irritating!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Reed Grimm is the standout

I would like to see Phillip Phillips Jr. on final 14... I love him

They are keeping cowboy guy because he is publicity..he and Courtney(girl who's man had a stroke) they're both average and she has a terrible attitude..diva without the talent..send cowboy home he a wannabe Scotty!

He's rude obnoxious and thinks his ##### don't stink! I will stop watching this show if I have to listen to another "Scotty"!!!!

I can't stand him! Judges wake up please!

I. Absolutely hate that howdy doo dee cowboy singer! pLEASE! Kick him off!!!!!! He is an a*****hole

nice program!!!nice performance!!!

all the vivid stomach flu footage has turned me off. First time in 10 years that I have NOT watched Idol. SO dissapointed in this year, and I hate to admit, I'm switching over to the Voice. Watching sick people sing, puke, pass out, try to sing, just isn't my idea of 'entertainment'.

What's the name of the guy with the white shirt who performed last night? And I don't also know the title of his song (Just only know the part.... "who do you think you are?"... Thanks!

great that you did this

Vegas...someday

Vegas...someday

Why wouldn't you explain to the first groups that their selection could be in jeopardy when they were selected vs after the selection when everyone thought they were safe! That's cruel!

What are the names of the ones that sung The Night has a Thousand eyes...?