so sad Paul voted out no thrilled for me to watch American Idol his my Idol

I really loved all of your performances Paul, you and Pia are my American Idols! Now without Paul and Pia, who happen to be the most good looking and hottest among the top 13 contestants, I think I'm done watching the rest of the American Idol season 10. So sad they were voted out early. I hope James Durbin will not be voted out next week. I believe in your talent Paul and don't ever be distracted with the haters... God bless you always.

You will definitely be missed. You have shown nothing but class throughout. You were a great contestant and everyone I know loved watching you. You made us smile every time you performed. Thank you and the very best of luck to you. I'll be in line to buy your CD.

Aw. :( He was my favorite! Best of luck to Paul - you are an extremely talented musician.

Paul I'm a fan. Please continue building your career. You have good character, talented and very charming. I love your music. Solo or with the Grand Magnolias you're gonna be great artist. Rock on!

WOW what a bummer my favorite was voted off! Paul - Best of luck and hope to see you hit it big (like Daughtry) - with you gone now and Pia last week - what's the point in watching.

Why did we have to say good bye to you , you are a wonderful singer keep doing what you do Best of luck to Paul

Paul should not have been voted off. I would have thrown Stephano out

this competion is so hard, everyone is so good. its hard to see anyone go. But someone has too............

Thank goodness we're starting to weed out the so-so singers. Paul has his own style... but it is DEFINETELY not the best of the lot.

Hi Paul, from Madison, AL. Was heartbroken to see you go, but know that you will be on the road to good things quickly! Please come back to us soon here in the Huntsville area as soon as you can. Make sure we have plenty of publicity! Although I am almost 61 I am a big fan, as is my hubby. I love your Maggie May! That song brings back many personal memories from when my husband and I first married in Aug '71. We will be married 40 yrs in Aug. Promise me that you will keep that gorgeous and contagious smile and magnetic personality! Onward and upward, Paul. Everyone here in the Madison/Huntsville area have been cheering for you and voting for you. Hope to see you soon. Love and blessings to you.
0 8:34AM, Apr 15, 2011
LinaMo27

Paul McDonald, you are incredible! I cannot wait to see what the future holds for you and your music. Never stop smiling, never stop the music, never let those amazing floral designs wilt, and never, EVER shut off your signature swagger ;) You are a star and my American Idol! We love you, Paul!!!

Paul, you are a gentleman. I wish the best and much success

Paul, you are an AMAZING and TALENTED musician. After seeing you, hearing you, discovering your music, and buying your Grand Mag and Hightide albums, I was never worried about how far you made it on Idol, because I know you'll make it with or without the title of Idol winner. Your voice, is one of a kind, and it touches me so much, I can't begin to describe. You will go far in this life, and in the business and I wish you so much success in your career. I can't wait to see you on the Idol tour, my girls and I will be cheering the loudest. Take care and don't ever change.

I know you will go far Paul! I was in total shock last night and still really put out that you aren't going to be back next week!
I really love your unique style and was also hoping another Alabamian would make it to the finale. I would wish you good luck, but you really don't need it, we will be hearing from you I just know it!

Paul McDonald, you are absolutly amazing. Idol wont be the same with out your smile. We'll all miss you but remebr I love you and it was a mistake to vote you off.

Paul you are one class act!! I'm looking forward to folling your career forever! Best voice and command of the stage I've been privledge to get to know on AI ever! I took your own words as my Signature on here "Dontcha be sad Ya'll" and did say by: Paul McDonald.. It's going to be sad Wednesday night.. But we are so amazingly proud of you!! God Speed!!

I will forever love you :-)

Paul, I am sad that we won't get to see you on AI anymore!! :( You are amazing!! It was a mistake for you to be voted off!! I wish you the best!!

I can't believe that you were voted off... You are awesome Paul...
Keep smiling because I love your smile and keep singing because I love your voice and the most important, you should start a world tour and you should come and sing in Roumania.
You've gain a huge fan out here...
Love you Paul... Keep doing what doing because you are doing it great!

you are totally amazing Paul , I am a huge fan of you, so sad to see you leave this competition. I just want to tell you that you are really talented and gonna have a big career. KEEPING SMILING PAUL!!!!! I love you!!!!!!!!

Paul i think your amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ILUV YOU PAUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i will always love you i will always love you!! foreveer!! PAUL YOU'RE MY ROCKET MAN !!!!

Paul, i am so upset that your not on AI anymore ! i cryed :/ your soooo good and amazing and you were so robbed ! your way better than Stefano ! i wanted you to winnn ! Love youuuu Paul your the besttt !!!!!!!

Been listening to the High Tide Blues CD for a year now...bought your Grand Magnolias CD off ITunes a few weeks back. Caught your act at the Loft in Atlanta last year (while my kid was watching the Honor Society perform upstairs). You are an awsome performer. So far, my favorite song of yours is "4:15." I have been sharing your music with anybody and everybody I can. I never watched Idol until you were on the show, and never will again. America Screwed up...you were and are by far the best performer Idol has ever had on the show. But, you got your exposure, now you can go about getting a new CD out...can't wait to buy it...hope it is as good as the first Grand Magnolia's CD. Good luck, and will be looking for more tunes from you. You are infectious man....everyone else, if you have never seen him perform live on stage doing his own music...you need to catch a show....he is GREAT!

I've watched you in Jay Leno Show and Regis & Kelly, again you proved that you have what it takes to be an American Idol. Confidence, voice, performance, charisma, wit. It comes so naturally of you and you look so good. Keep rockin! Will definitely follow your journey.

imma goin to miss you paul!!!

Nice guy but should have been voted off weeks ago. Every song he sings sounds the same...no range, weak voice. I usually agree with the judges but I really don't know why they think he's so great.

Miss you already Paul, can't wait for your record to come out! I know you'll have 1

Paul, your a true gentleman and your attitude is just awesome. I wish you the best on Idol tour and in your future. Like you said AI was a great platform for you to share your voice and personality.

You have some great days ahead dude!

God Bless,
Steven

Thank you for what you do. I have a top 6 & it is now a top 5. I'm sorry to see you go, but know that you will do great. I look forward to seeing you in the future! With your attitude & class act, I think you will do very well. Good luck Paul!

Paul i am going to miss you...you were my favorite...I really hated to see you go...I voted for you millions of times and you still didn't make it...keep doing what you doing because to me you are great...

I loved Paul. I think if he had chosen more songs by Rod Stewart and Bob Dylan, he would still be in the competition.
Why oh why did he not sign Maggie May earlier?

Paul, I am going to miss you......I grew up with Rod Stewart...and then I heard you..WOW....I will look for you in the future....I will buy your records!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Stay true to YOU!!

Always a Rock and Roller.......

so sorry paul was voted offf ; He has the smile the voice and addatiude one greta person; love u paul

Sorry to see Paul go. He was among my favorites and very entertaining. Great singer with an even greater personality. What a smile!

Paul keep the band together even tho your going ...keep them all together because you all are great singers !!

my mom loves you she and i cried when you left. you will win next year never give up all was chase your dream.

I am so going to miss you on AI....Paul you are truly a great performer I love your original music you have to bring your band Vancouver Canada

Paul you are a real ROCKER ,keep on going
I will buy your Music

Paul, you were my moms favorite. She loved the song that you sang. "Maggie May". It was her favorite song by rod stewart. and she's glad you made it this far. ! (:

I will miss you Stephano. you are a real man. you have what it takes. you have the energy and I can see that you will not give up....I can see you out there ....I wish you good luck and God bless you to keep on sharing your talent...

Ahhh Stefano's little pep talk to his fans at the end really cheered me up...Stefano, you are the best and you will have my support always!!!

Stefano, I think your talk was the thing that cheered me up... can't wait till your own music comes out:D I am a huge fan of you , like a huge fan:D I love you and wish you so much luck!!

I don't believe... first Pia now Paul... the America does not know how to vote... I'm shocked!!!

stefano. you're the one, look forward to hearing from you soon. here's a fan. Ruben. from Uruguay.

Everytime I watch Pauls curtian call, I remember WHY he was my favorite!! Super classy guy!! Humble Man who's gonna be even more famous than he already was!!!!

Can't wait to buy ur CD!

LOVE!

We have not heard the last of Casey!!!! He is so talented and i will buy his cds!!!!