Jena stuck to her roots and performed "Bring Me To Life" by Evanescence. While Harry noted previously that it would be hard to follow Caleb's rocking performanc,e he admitted that Jena definitely did just that, adding that it was "really, really strong." Keith continued with his line of car based feedback and said "You got your own lane" in response to Jena's performance. Jennifer thought that Jena sounded "phenomenal," but wished that she had been more "messy" on stage. That comment earned the IDOL audience the second hair flip of the season from Jennifer Lopez! May there be many more to come.