Malaya chose to perform The Beatles classic, "The Long and Winding Road" with a bit of a Gospel twist. The audience was entranced, but were the judges? Keith started off the criticism saying "Gosh that was beautiful, baby." He added that the performance showed him her "spirit." Jennifer thought her voice stands out and added that it sounds like a "young Michael Jackson." Harry gave Malaya the award for "most consistently approving" and praised Malaya for listening to their critiques.