Jennifer Lopez observed as quickly as we did how attractive Spencer Lloyd is. The Worship Leader performed "Never Gone" by Idol's own Colton Dixon, but he played it on the guitar instead of the piano. The judges thought he was good, but maybe not the best they've ever heard. His whole package was enough to give him three yeses, and women (and men) across America rejoiced! Spencer's family sure knows how to rejoice -- one guy picked up Ryan Seacrest, and the ladies' screams made Harry wonder if it was shrieks of horror or delight.