"The next person to sing for their life, not to make it dramatic or anything, is Spencer Lloyd," Jennifer announced. How could it be any less dramatic? Spencer took the stage performing his original song "Ordinary Girl," which wasn't a huge hit with the judges back during Hollywood Week. It wasn't a big hit with them this time around, either. Jennifer said that while she wanted to give him a chance, she wasn't "sure that's what we wanted America to see in this moment."