Johnny Newcomb was the first contestant the judges asked to sing again. He strapped on his guitar for a rendition of Foster The People's "Pumped Up Kicks." The judges weren't wild about it, but the performance had his fellow contestants grooving. We don't know Connor Zwetsch, but we quickly learned that she likes to wear unattractive headgear when she sings. Connor gave a pretty delivery of "Let Her Go." Ali Jane Henderson gave a stripped down version of Britney Spears' "Toxic." Those were some good song choices and versions from the first three contestants!