It was Gwen Stefani week on American Idol, and the viewpoints on the MyIdol Message Boards are about as varied as Phil Staceys hats. Read below for a sampling of whats being discussed. Have something to add? By all means, be our guestor even better, be a member! Start a thread or write a fan recap. If we really like your fan recap, we might even use it as our official show recap for Americanidol.com. Or we might just use an excerpt or two to spread the Idol word on the grapevine. Either way, we want to hear what you have to say!

Donna Summer would have a tough time topping that amazing performance and I honestly think Melinda did a better version. "jaduck

This was my favorite performance from Gina so far. This song, I felt, was perfectly suited to her voice, particularly because she has that little "ism" of falling off at the end of her phrases. It works for this song. I thought she looked the part, felt the part and sang the part. Well done. "ProVocalist

Phil is not my favorite guy, but tonight I really thought he did excellent! I'm not sure he has a strong following, but I would guess that tonight it may have gotten stronger. I thought that his song selection was perhaps the best of the night. It brought out the true beauty of his voice. "jimpam86

(Chris Richardson) I really, really liked this. Gwen was worried about his Vocal Olympics, but I dont think she needed to. He only used what was necessary to make it work for him. He was bopping again, but hes toned it down quite a bit, so Ill give him a pass on that. I enjoyed the performance. "dchambers59

Blake has that Euro feel/vibe about him. He returns to straight up singing. O.K., vocally, it wasn't amazing. However, even when you have your back turned you can feel the groove in his voice. He is right there where he needs to be in a song. It's impeccable. "pieceandluv2

Sligh can take comfort in the fact that he's a genuinely good singer. He has his own personality and it extends to his music. I thought his choice tonight was very interesting. The start was absolutely superbsublime vocals. Once he finished the chorus, the band and the singer seemed to have divorced on stage. They were out of sync. He was a step ahead and the band was chopping through trees, rowing upstream in the Amazon and fighting anacondas to get to him. "Sabier

Jordin takes big risks and it is paying off for her. Hey Baby isn't easy to carry-off, but she had no problem with it, except for the slow start. She also looked young and fresh, as noted by Gwen. I'm hoping against hope that she keeps on improving and becomes the next American Idol."Damien666

Haley Scarnato " True Colors - That was sweet. It was light and simplethe kind of performance that really doesn't grab anyone at all in anyway, bad or good. She should stick to the sexy upbeat pop star stuff like last week--that's where she'll get the votes, but this was nice. "Stumpythewalrus

Wearing extensions from the Gina Glocksen collection, LaKisha finishes her song with a note so massive that light is temporarily unable to escape from her mouth. Randy sums up LaKishas performance as resembling that of a true, fly diva. --onemanswarm

If one of the goals of American Idol is to find someone interesting, original, creative and unique, we can stop looking. Creating the one truly captivating, memorable event of the evening was Sanjaya. The look was amazing! It was of the Boy George, Liberace, Prince variety--and I mean the flamboyancy. "Deanie79